跨区域政府间合作何以可能?——基于绩效目标差异背景下食品安全监管的分析

doi:10.16088/j.issn.1001-6597.2021.03.004

摘要/Abstract

摘要： 政府间合作成为当前我国公共管理实践的重要现象,在一定程度上改变了我国地方政府间以竞争为主的关系现状。为实现食品安全和脱贫攻坚的“双赢”,绩效目标差异的两地在食品监管领域基于监管人员和监管工具合作的不同组合,形成了合作程度不同的合作模式,如综合型合作、信息型合作、实体型合作与消费型合作等。基于“成本—收益”的分析思路,研究发现,历史合作关系和现实财政联系产生了合作的直接成本和间接成本,而示范称号的获得与负面事件的发生传递出不同性质的符号,改变了两地开展合作的收益预期,上述四点变化影响了两地合作的可能性和合作的程度。研究地方政府监管合作的动机,可以为压力型体制下我国地方政府行为趋势研究提供边际贡献,为接下来开展的乡村振兴东西部协作提供前瞻。

关键词: 食品安全监管, 跨区域政府间合作, 成本—收益, 乡村振兴, 治理现代化

Abstract: Inter-governmental cooperation,serving as an important phenomenon in the public administration in China, has changed, to a certain extent,the competition oriented relationship between local governments. Two local governments with different performance objectives but a common target to achieve a win-win results on food safety and poverty alleviation, cooperate with models, such as comprehensive cooperation, information-based cooperation, entity-based cooperation and consumption cooperation, different in degree of food supervision based on different combinations of supervisors and supervision tools.This paper, based on the analysis of “cost-benefit”, finds that the historical cooperative relationship and the real financial connection produce the direct and indirect costs of cooperation, while the acquisition of the model title and the occurrence of negative events convey different symbols changing the income expectation of the cooperation. Changes of such sort at length decide the possibility and degree of their cooperation. The research on the motivation of local government cooperation on supervision provides marginal contribution for the research on the behavior trend of local government in China under the pressure system, and offers a perspective for cooperation between China’s east and west regions on the next stage of rural revitalization.

Key words: food safety supervision, cross-regional inter-governmental cooperation, cost-benefit, rural revitalization, governance modernization

中图分类号:

D630.1

刘志鹏. 跨区域政府间合作何以可能?——基于绩效目标差异背景下食品安全监管的分析[J]. 广西师范大学学报（哲学社会科学版）, 2021, 57(3): 28-39.

LIU Zhi-peng. How Can Cross-regional Inter-governmental Cooperation Be Possible?—An Analysis of Food Safety Administration Based on Performance Target Difference[J]. Journal of Guangxi Teachers Education University (Philosophy and Social Sciences Edition), 2021, 57(3): 28-39.

参考文献

[1] Liu Peng, McGuire W H. One regulatory state,two regulatory regimes:understanding dual regimesin China's regulatory
state building through food safety[J]. Journal of Contemporary China,2015(91):119-136.
[2] 魏延安. 当前农村电商的七个问题[J]. 中国信息界,2019(5):48-49.
[3] 王清. 政府部门间为何合作:政绩共容体的分析框架[J]. 中国行政管理,2018(7):100-107.
[4] Spencer Henson, Julie Caswell.Food safety regulation:an overview of contemporary issues[J]. Food Policy,1999(6):589-603.
[5] Ian Ayres, John Braithwaite.Tripartism:regulatory capture and empowerment[J]. Laws & Social Inquiry,1991(3):435-496.
[6] Thomson A, Perry J.Collaboration processes:inside the black box[J]. Public Administration Review,2006(S1):20-32.
[7] Ansell C,Gash A.Collaborative governance in theory and practice[J]. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2008(4):543-571.
[8] Emerson K,Nabatchi T,Balogh S.An integrative framework for collaborative governance[J]. Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory,2012(1):1-29.
[9] Gerber E,Henry A D,Lubell M.Political homophily and collaboration in regional planning networks[J]. American Journal of Political Science,2013(3):598-610.
[10] Weible C,Sabatier P.Comparing policy networks:marine protected areas in California[J]. Policy Studies Journal,2005:181-201.
[11] Snijders T,Van De Bunt G,Steglich C. Introduction to stochastic actor-based models for network dynamics[J]. Social Networks,2010(1):44-60.
[12] Zhang G.The revolutions in China’s inter-governmental fiscal system[J]. Public Money & Management,2018(6):419-426.
[13] Yang H,Chen S,Zhou Y.Local government competition and environmental policy:empirical evidence from province' s governments in China[J]. South China Journal of Economics,2008(6):15-30.
[14] Lampton D M.Water:challenge to fragmented political system[C]// Lampton D M(ed). Policy Implementation in Post-Mao China. Berkley:University of California Press,1987.
[15] Xie B,Ye L,Shao Z.Managing and financing metropolitan public services in China:experience of the Pearl River Delta region[J].Public Money & Management,2018(6):445-452.
[16] 谢宝剑,陈瑞莲. 国家治理视野下的大气污染区域联动防治体系研究[J]. 中国行政管理,2014(9):6-10.
[17] 王登临,兀征,杨虎,等. 甘肃省探索建立动物跨区域调运监管机制的研究[J]. 甘肃畜牧兽医,2015(5):79-80.
[18] 徐国冲,霍龙霞. 食品安全合作监管的生成逻辑——基于2000-2017 年政策文本的实证分析[J]. 公共管理学报,2020(1):18-30.
[19] Chu M,Wang J.Central-local collaboration in regulating food safety in China[J]. Public Money & Management,2018(6):437-444.
[20] 杨龙. 地方政府合作的动力、过程与机制[J]. 中国行政管理,2008(7):96-99.
[21] 孙兵. 晋升博弈背景下中国地方政府合作发展研究[J]. 南开学报(哲学社会科学版),2013(2): 23-30.
[22] 王鹏. 跨域治理视角下地方政府间关系及其协调路径研究[J]. 贵州社会科学,2013(2):142-147.
[23] Phillimore J.Understanding intergovernmental relations:key features and trends[J]. Australian Journal of Public Administration,2013,72(3):228-238.
[24] Margot P,Stanbury W T,Thompson F.On the definition of economic regulation[C]// Stanbury W T (ed). Government regulation:scope,growth,process. Montreal:Institute for Research on Public Policy,1980.
[25] 刘鹏,刘志鹏. 社会性监管机构的能力差异及原因——基于八个中央机构的定性评估[J]. 公共管理学报,2017(1):75-88.
[26] OECD. Recommendation of the council of the OECD on Improving the quality of government regulation[R]. Paris:OECD/GD,1995.
[27] [英]丹尼斯·C. 缪勒.公共选择理论[M]. 杨春学,译. 北京:中国社会科学出版社,1999.
[28] March J G, Olsen J P.Rediscovering institutions:the organizational basis of politics[M]. New York:Free Press,1989.
[29] Mishan E J.Cost-benefit analysis(4th edition)[M].New York:Routledge,1994.
[30] Hancher L,Moran M.Organizing regulatory space[C]// Hancher L, Moran M. Capitalism,culture and economic regulation. Oxford:Clarendon Press,1989.
[31] Peters B G.Institutional theory in political science[M].London and New York:Wellington House,1999.
[32] 代凯. 注意力分配:研究政府行为的新视角[J]. 理论月刊,2017(3):107-112.
[33] 陈科霖. “应急管理碎片化”的成因及其消解——基于常规与应急两种治理机制的比较分析[J]. 广西师范大学学报(哲学社会科学版),2020(6):45-58.
[34] 章文光,刘志鹏. 注意力视角下政策冲突中地方政府的行为逻辑——基于精准扶贫的案例分析[J]. 公共管理学报,2020(4):152-162.
[35] 王印红,李萌竹. 地方政府生态环境治理注意力研究——基于30 个省市政府工作报告(2006–2015)文本分析[J]. 中国人口·资源与环境,2017(2):28-35.

Metrics

Viewed

Full text

Abstract

Cited

Shared

Discussed